HomeScienceThe Olympics shifts away from testosterone tests and toward human rights

The Olympics shifts away from testosterone tests and toward human rights

master mentalism tricks

Credit: Pixabay/CC0 Public Domain

The International Olympic Committee (IOC) this week released a much anticipated policy document aimed at making the Olympics more inclusive for transgender athletes and athletes with sex variations.

The new framework builds on more than two years of consultation with diverse athletes, advocates, and stakeholders.

The devil will be in the detail and implementation, of course. But this fresh approach, which places human rights at the center, could herald a new era of gender-inclusive sports participation and governance.

Why this new framework—and why now?

One of the most prominent gender equity and human rights issues of recent years has been the inclusion of gender-minoritised people—those whose bodies and/or gender expression and identity do not neatly align with normative notions of the female/male binary.

This issue affects sport globally from grassroots to elite levels. Stakeholders have long called for change.

We work with sports organizations and athletes grappling with the question of inclusion in women’s sport.

Our own research has highlighted that many sports organizations develop policies with little to no knowledge of the complexity of the issue—and often without engaging the athletes affected.

The new IOC framework follows a long and much-critiqued history of efforts to define the boundaries of the female athlete category, dating back to the “nude parades” of the 1960s.

In the past, the goal has been to find a “biological basis of womanhood” and relied on incomplete and controversial scientific evidence.

Today, however, there is wider recognition of the fact science alone cannot provide a straightforward answer to such as socially and biologically complex question.

An alternative approach, reflected in the IOC’s new framework, is to build policy around the concept of human rights.

What do the new guidelines say?

The new framework recognize human rights as a fundamental responsibility of sports governing bodies.

It explicitly takes the approach athletes shouldn’t be excluded solely on the basis of their transgender identity or sex variations. It aims to ensure everyone can practice sport safely and free from harassment, irrespective of their gender or sex-linked traits.

Importantly, the framework attempts to move sports governing bodies away from relying on testosterone as a one-size-fits-all measure of eligibility.

In its place, it emphasizes ten key principles to guide the policy development process:

  • prevention of harm
  • non-discrimination
  • fairness
  • no presumption of advantage
  • evidence-based approaches to regulation
  • the primacy of health and bodily autonomy
  • a stakeholder-centered approach to rule development
  • the right to privacy
  • periodic review of eligibility regulations.

The relationship between testosterone and performance is so complex, sports governing bodies cannot realistically expect to rely on testosterone measures when defining eligibility.

There is just as much diversity among the bodies and performances of trans women and women with sex variations as we see among cisgender and normatively-bodied women athletes.

The IOC’s spokespeople were pragmatic: let’s take one step at a time, have faith in the ten principles, and see where they take us.

In this way, the new framework (and its underlying philosophy) moves us well beyond contentious testosterone thresholds introduced in 2015 and the 2003 Stockholm consensus, which required athletes to have affirmation surgeries and “anatomical changes.”

In fact, the IOC now recognizes the “severe harm” and systemic discrimination caused by such eligibility criteria and policies.

This includes the disproportionate burdens and harms that have been wrought upon women of color from Global South nations in sports like track and field.

The question now is: how will other sports governing bodies, most notably the International Federations (IFs) that govern each Olympic sport, be brought on side?

The IOC now calls for IFs to take “a principled approach to develop their criteria that are applicable to their sport.”

An important and welcome move

This framework represents a step forward for gender-inclusive sport but there’s more work ahead. It doesn’t mention non-binary athletes at all, meaning it still frames elite sports participation within a strict gender binary.

It’s promising to see a shift away from a paradigm focused on particular scientific and medical approaches regulating exclusion of certain groups. The move toward a contemporary vision of gender-inclusive sport is promising.

This new approach is a positive move for gender equitable sport; both trans women and women with sex variations will be valuable allies in the fight to make sport safe and inclusive for all women.

Hopefully, it will help make grassroots a more welcome space for trans and gender diverse people. These groups report alarming levels of poor mental health and suicidal ideation and have a right to opportunities to improve wellbeing through sport.

Sport has a unique opportunity to advance progress and health outcomes for marginalized communities.

This move may offer hope to young people of diverse genders and sex that they too can strive to achieve greatness in a sport they love.

The debate over transgender athletes’ rights is testing the current limits of science and the law Provided by The Conversation

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

Citation: The Olympics shifts away from testosterone tests and toward human rights (2021, November 19) retrieved 13 December 2021 from

This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

Read The Full Article Here

trick photography

Popular posts

Steven Yeun Cast In Marvel’s ‘Thunderbolts’
We Asked a Chatbot Why 25 Classic Movies Are So
The Big Door Prize Trailer Wants to Unlock Your True
Champions Interview: Bobby Farrelly on Modern Comedy & Woody Harrelson
2023 Season Finale Dates: When Will Your Favorite Shows Be
The Real Housewives of Salt Lake City Star Jen Shah’s
Julianne Hough Returns to Dancing With the Stars as Co-Host
Accused Sneak Peek: Jack Puts it All On the Line
The Weeknd’s HBO Show The Idol Mired in Chaos, Future
Sam Neill in remission after being diagnosed with blood cancer
Se7en & Actress Lee Da-hae Announce They Are Getting Married
Courtney Love accuses Rock & Roll Hall of Fame of
Summer Fridays Drops New Lip Butter Balm Shades + More
Michael Kors Relaunches the Iconic Astor Bag + More Fashion
‘House of the Dragon’ Season 2 Will Introduce ‘Five New
6 Timeless Loafer Trends That You’re About to See Everywhere
Support the Trans Rights Readathon with These Heartwarming Novels
Books Continue To Be Prime Source for Film Content
Oprah Makes Her 100th Book Club Selection
An Overthinker’s Guide to Giving Book Recommendations
IPCC Report Will Likely Shake Up U
Evolution of supersoft X-ray source WX Centauri is dominated by
Heat waves are hitting the deep ocean floor, with potentially
Better eyewitness lineup improves accuracy, detecting innocence
Reliance Jio to Launch 5G Services in Rajasthan on October
Google Antitrust Fine ‘Provisional’ as CCI Awaits Requisite Financial Details
In Bulgaria, Russian Trolls Are Winning the Information War
Apple’s Industrial Design Head Evans Hankey to Step Down